Radioactive elements in Cassiopeia A suggest a neutrino-driven explosion

Time evolution of the radioactive element nickel (56Ni) in the ejecta of a 3D simulation of a neutrino-driven supernova explosion. The images show the non-spherical distribution from shortly after the onset of the explosion (3.25 seconds) until a late time (6236 seconds) when the final asymmetry is determined. The colours represent radial velocities according to the scales given for each panel. Credit: © MPA

Stars exploding as supernovae are the main sources of heavy chemical elements in the Universe. In particular, radioactive atomic nuclei are synthesized in the hot, innermost regions during the explosion and can thus serve as probes of the unobservable physical processes that initiate the blast. Using elaborate computer simulations, a team of researchers from the Max Planck Institute for Astrophysics (MPA) and RIKEN in Japan were able to explain the recently measured spatial distributions of radioactive titanium and nickel in Cassiopeia A, a roughly 340 year old gaseous remnant of a nearby supernova. The computer models yield strong support for the theoretical idea that such stellar death events can be initiated and powered by neutrinos escaping from the neutron star left behind at the origin of the explosion.

Massive stars end their lives in gigantic explosions, so-called supernovae. Within millions of years of stable evolution, these stars have built up a central core composed of mostly iron. When the core reaches about 1.5 times the mass of the Sun, it collapses under the influence of its own gravity and forms a neutron star. Enormous amounts of energy are released in this catastrophic event, mostly by the emission of neutrinos. These nearly massless elementary particles are abundantly produced in the interior of the new-born neutron star, where the density is higher than in atomic nuclei and the temperature can reach 500 billion degrees Kelvin.

The physical processes that trigger and drive the have been an unsolved puzzle for more than 50 years. One of the theoretical mechanisms proposed invokes the neutrinos, because they carry away more than hundred times the energy needed for a typical . As the neutrinos leak out from the hot interior of the neutron star, a small fraction of them is absorbed in the surrounding gas. This heating causes violent motions of the gas, similar to those in a pot of boiling water. When the bubbling of the gas becomes sufficiently powerful, the supernova explosion sets in as if the lid of the pot was blown off. The outer layers of the dying star are then expelled into circumstellar space, and with them all the chemical elements that the star has assembled by nuclear burning during its life. But also new elements are created in the hot ejecta of the explosion, among them radioactive species such as titanium (44Ti with 22 protons and 22 neutrons) and nickel (56Ni with 28 neutrons and protons each), which decay to stable calcium and iron, respectively. The radioactive energy thus released makes the supernova shine bright for many years.

Observed distribution of radioactive titanium (44Ti, blue) and iron (white, red) in Cassiopeia A. The visible iron is mostly the radioactive decay product of radioactive nickel (56Ni). The yellow cross marks the geometrical centre of the explosion, the white cross and the arrow indicate the current location and the direction of motion of the neutron star. Copyright: Macmillan Publishers Ltd: Nature; from Grefenstette et al., Nature 506, 339 (2014); Fe distribution courtesy of U.~Hwang.

Because of the wild boiling of the neutrino-heated gas, the blast wave starts out non-spherically and imprints a large-scale asymmetry on the ejected stellar matter and the supernova as a whole (Fig. 1), in agreement with the observation of clumpiness and asymmetries in many supernovae and their gaseous remnants. The initial asymmetry of the explosion has two immediate consequences. On the one hand, the neutron star receives a recoil momentum opposite to the direction of the stronger explosion, where the supernova gas is expelled with more violence. This effect is similar to the kick a rowing boat receives when a passenger jumps off. On the other hand, the production of heavy elements from silicon to iron, in particular also of titanium and nickel, is more efficient in directions where the explosion is stronger and where more matter is heated to high temperatures.

“We have predicted both effects some years ago by our three-dimensional (3-D) simulations of neutrino-driven supernova explosions”, says Annop Wongwathanarat, researcher at RIKEN and lead author of the corresponding publication of 2013, when he worked at MPA in collaboration with his co-authors H.-Thomas Janka and Ewald Müller. “The asymmetry of the radioactive ejecta is more pronounced if the neutron star kick is larger”, he adds. Since the radioactive atomic nuclei are synthesized in the innermost regions of the supernova, in very close vicinity to the neutron star, their spatial distribution reflects explosion asymmetries most directly.

New observations of Cassiopeia A (Cas A), the gaseous remnant of a supernova whose light reached the Earth around the year 1680, could now confirm this theoretical prediction. Because of its young age and relative proximity at a distance of just 11,000 light years, Cas A offers two great advantages for measurements. First, the radioactive decay of 44Ti is still an efficient energy source and releases high-energy X-ray radiation, therefore the presence of this atomic nucleus can be mapped in 3-D with high precision. Second, the velocity of the neutron star is known with both its magnitude and its direction on the plane of the sky. Since the neutron star propagates with an estimated speed of at least 350 kilometres per second, the asymmetry in the spatial distribution of the radioactive elements is expected to be very pronounced. Exactly this is seen in the observations (Fig. 2a).

Observable radioactive nickel (56Ni, green) and titanium (44Ti, blue) as predicted by the 3D simulation of a neutrino-driven supernova explosion shown in Fig. 1. The orientation is optimized for closest possible similarity to the Cas A image of Fig. 2a. The neutron star is marked by a white cross and shifted away from the centre of the explosion (red plus symbol) because of its kick velocity. The neutron star motion points away from the hemisphere that contains most of the ejected 44Ti. Iron (the decay product of Ni56) can be observed only in an outer, hot shell of Cas A. Credit: © MPA

While the compact remnant speeds toward the lower hemisphere, the biggest and brightest clumps with most of the 44Ti are found in the upper half of the gas remnant. The computer simulation, viewed from a suitably chosen direction, exhibits a striking similarity to the observational image (Fig. 2b). This can also be seen when comparing the 3-D visualisation of the simulations in Fig. 3 with the 3-D imaging of Cas A ( , ).

But not only the spatial distributions of titanium and iron resemble those in Cas A. Also the total amounts of these elements, their expansion velocities, and the velocity of the neutron star are in amazing agreement with those of Cas A. “This ability to reproduce basic properties of the observations impressively confirms that Cas A may be the remnant of a neutrino-driven supernova with its violent gas motions around the nascent star”, concludes H.-Thomas Janka.

But more work is needed to finally prove that the explosions of massive are indeed powered by energy input from neutrinos. “Cas A is an object of so much interest and importance that we must also understand the spatial distributions of other chemical species such as silicon, argon, neon, and oxygen”, remarks Ewald Müller, pointing to the beautiful multi-component morphology of Cas A revealed by 3-D imaging. Just having one example is also not enough for making a fully convincing case. Therefore the team has joined a bigger collaboration to test the theoretical predictions for neutrino-driven explosions by a close analysis of a larger sample of young supernova remnants. Step by step the researchers thus hope to collect evidence to be able to settle the long-standing problem of the supernova mechanism.

More information: Annop Wongwathanarat et al. Production and Distribution ofTi andNi in a Three-dimensional Supernova Model Resembling Cassiopeia A, The Astrophysical Journal (2017). DOI: 10.3847/1538-4357/aa72de ,

Provided by: Max Planck Society